In an attempt to follow through on a significant campaign pledge that he has not yet been able to deliver on, President Joe Biden is making another attempt to erase student loans.
During a Monday visit to Wisconsin, Biden unveiled a plan that would erase at least a portion of debt for over 30 million Americans. Months after the Supreme Court turned down Biden’s initial attempt at mass cancellation, it has been in the works.
Though he referred to the court’s ruling as a “mistake,” Biden directed the Education Department to develop a new strategy based on an alternative legal authority. Compared to his initial idea, the most recent approach is more focused and targets people for whom school debt is a significant barrier.
What is known about the revised plan is as follows:
In What Way Does This Differ From Biden’s First Plan?
In Biden’s initial attempt to cancel student loans on a large scale, up to $125,000 in annual income would have been wiped, plus an extra $10,000 if the borrower was a recipient of government Pell awards for low-income students. Over 40 million people would have at least a portion of their school debt canceled, and the anticipated $400 billion cost would be met.
Last year, the Supreme Court dismissed that proposal, stating that Biden had overreached his jurisdiction.
The Higher Education Act, which gives the education secretary the authority to forgive student loan debt under specific circumstances, is the alternative legal basis for the new scheme. A federal regulatory procedure has been initiated by the Education Department to provide clarification on the secretary’s jurisdiction.
With an emphasis on individuals deemed to be most in need of assistance, the new approach targets five different types of debtors. About 30 million borrowers would benefit from it. The cost of the scheme has not been disclosed by the administration.
Who is Qualified?
Five types of debtors would be eligible for cancellation under Biden’s proposed plan.
The most comprehensive provision seeks to reset the amounts of student loans for borrowers whose debt has increased due to unpaid interest. It would eliminate interest payments of up to $20,000 for Americans who presently owe more than they borrowed. Individuals earning less than $120,000 annually or couples making less than $240,000 annually who are also enrolled in an income-driven repayment plan are exempt from this cap.
According to the Education Department, that assistance would be available to 25 million people, of whom 23 million would have their interest completely waived.
Under the proposed plan, borrowers who are qualified for other government forgiveness programs but haven’t applied would also have their debts erased. It covers a variety of programs, including income-driven repayment plans and the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program. It is intended to assist those who were denied forgiveness due to difficult documentation, poor counsel, or other challenges. It is predicted that 2 million individuals will be in need of that assistance.
For borrowers who have been repaying their undergraduate loans for twenty years or longer—or for twenty-five years if they have debt from graduate school—all of their debt would be forgiven. More than two million people would have their loans forgiven, according to the Biden administration.
Forgiveness would be granted to those who enrolled in “low financial value” college programs. For borrowers who attended schools that were no longer eligible for federal education assistance due to student fraud, the scheme would eliminate debt. Additionally, loans for those who attended college programs that resulted in low wages for graduates relative to their student loans would be canceled.
For Americans in the last group, loans would be canceled if their financial circumstances prevented them from repaying their student debts. The regulation would establish an application process for people to describe various types of hardship and would let the Education Department cancel debt for borrowers who are deemed extremely likely to default on their loans.
Is an Application Required?
The majority of the cancellations would occur automatically; no application would be required. This would apply to individuals who attended low-value programs, borrowers with older debts, those who qualified for alternative cancellation schemes, and interest cancellation.
There is one exception: each borrower would have to petition on their own behalf if they would like to argue that their circumstances warrant cancellation.
When Will I Be Able to Rest?
According to the Biden administration, certain debts, including interest that has accumulated on top of customers’ debts, may be erased as soon as this autumn.
It would take some wrangling to fit that schedule. According to the Education Department, a formal proposal will be made public in the “coming months.” A sixty-day window for public comment would typically follow that. The following July, or July 2025 in this example, would normally see the implementation of the regulation if it is approved by November 1.
However, the Higher Education Act gives the education secretary the authority to expedite regulations for “early implementation” under specific circumstances. Recently, the Biden administration took advantage of this authority to hasten the cancellation of student loans that are available under a new government repayment scheme. Biden could be able to begin eliminating debt later this year if he uses that authority.
Is This a True Deal?
anything but that. According to the Biden administration, it is certain that the Higher Education Act will approve the plan. However, since this kind of debt cancellation is unprecedented, Biden’s idea is likely to face legal challenges from conservative opponents.
Republicans have opposed Biden’s proposal to erase student loans on many occasions, arguing that taxpayers who paid back their debts or did not attend college should not be entitled to this unjust advantage. The Supreme Court made it apparent to opponents that Congress needed to act to cancel many loans.
Should Biden’s proposal be sued, the government may be forced to postpone its cancellation until the legal issues are resolved. In such a case, the idea may be shelved after the November presidential election. Biden’s plan will very certainly fail, even if it makes it through judicial challenges. A triumph by Donald Trump would be disastrous.
Can I Recancel a Cancellation?
In the event that the government reverses Biden’s plan once student loan cancellations begin, a difficult question would arise: Can student debts that have been forgiven ever again be forgiven?
There are technical methods for canceled student loans to be repaid. However, implementing it on such a broad scale would be challenging and expensive, requiring loan servicers hired by the Education Department to put in a lot of overtime.
Restoring debt after it has been forgiven might also be politically problematic. The courts may ultimately have the final say on how to handle debt that has already been canceled.
Related:
Republican states filed a lawsuit contesting Biden’s student loan repayment plan.
Biden administration announces $1.5 billion loan for first reopening of a closed nuclear plant.
Meet the billionaire who backed Trump’s $175 million bond.