Bastrop, Texas, is known for its charming small-town vibe, beautiful historic districts, and vibrant food scene. If you’re a pizza lover visiting or living in Bastrop, you’re in luck! The city boasts several fantastic pizza spots that cater to all tastes—from classic thin crusts to creative toppings and gourmet pies.

Whether you’re craving a quick slice or a cozy sit-down meal, these top four places in Bastrop will deliver on flavor, freshness, and atmosphere. Read on to discover where to find the best pizza in town.

1. Pie in the Sky Pizza – A Slice Above the Rest

Located just off downtown Bastrop, Pie in the Sky Pizza has become a local favorite for its mouthwatering pies and friendly vibe. Known for its perfectly chewy crust, fresh ingredients, and generous toppings, this pizzeria has something for everyone.

Their menu features classic options like Margherita, Pepperoni, and Meat Lovers, but they also offer inventive specialty pizzas such as the “Texas BBQ Chicken” and the “Veggie Supreme,” loaded with locally sourced vegetables. What truly sets Pie in the Sky apart is their commitment to quality. The dough is hand-tossed daily, and they use a blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese that melts beautifully.

The ambiance is casual and family-friendly, with picnic-style seating and occasional live music on weekends, making it a perfect spot to enjoy a pizza night with friends or family. Don’t forget to try their garlic knots and house-made ranch dipping sauce for the perfect accompaniment.

2. The Bakehouse Pizza & Grill – Crafting Artisan Pizzas with Heart

If you appreciate artisan-style pizza with a gourmet twist, The Bakehouse Pizza & Grill should be your next stop in Bastrop. This charming eatery offers a cozy dining experience with an emphasis on handcrafted recipes and fresh ingredients.

Their signature thin crust pizza is a standout, cooked to crispy perfection with a slight char that adds depth of flavor. The Bakehouse prides itself on sourcing local produce and meats, supporting Bastrop’s farming community while delivering a fresh taste.

Popular choices here include the “Fig & Prosciutto” pizza, which pairs sweet fig preserves with salty prosciutto and creamy goat cheese, and the “Spicy Italian” featuring Italian sausage, pepperoncini, and a spicy marinara sauce. For those who want a lighter option, they offer gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese upon request.

The Bakehouse also has a great selection of craft beers and wines to complement your meal, and the staff is always happy to recommend pairings. Whether you come for lunch or dinner, the friendly atmosphere and delicious pizzas make it a Bastrop must-try.

3. Paul’s Pizza Parlor – The Classic Bastrop Experience

For those who love the nostalgic feel of a traditional pizza parlor, Paul’s Pizza Parlor is a cornerstone of Bastrop’s pizza scene. This family-owned spot has been serving up classic New York-style pizzas for over two decades.

Paul’s offers a thick, foldable crust with a perfect balance of sauce and cheese, creating that quintessential pizza experience many crave. Their menu is simple but reliable, with staples like Cheese, Pepperoni, Sausage, and their famous “Paul’s Special,” which combines pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.

The vibe at Paul’s is warm and inviting, decorated with vintage photos and sports memorabilia. It’s a great place to catch a game on TV while enjoying a hot slice. Their daily specials and combo deals are budget-friendly, making it a great option for families and students alike.

Besides pizza, Paul’s Pizza Parlor also offers tasty wings, calzones, and a variety of salads, making it easy to customize your meal. If you’re after a comforting, no-frills pizza experience, Paul’s is the place to be in Bastrop.

4. Bastrop Pizza Co. – Where Tradition Meets Innovation

Bastrop Pizza Co. combines the best of traditional pizza-making techniques with innovative toppings and modern flair. This spot is perfect for adventurous eaters who want to try something new without sacrificing the classic pizza foundation.

The crust here is hand-stretched and baked in a stone oven, giving it a perfect texture—crispy on the outside, soft and airy inside. The menu offers a rotating selection of seasonal pizzas, often featuring unexpected ingredients like smoked brisket, roasted poblano peppers, or honey drizzle.

A popular favorite is their “Bastrop BBQ” pizza, loaded with smoked brisket, red onions, cheddar cheese, and a tangy barbecue sauce base. Another crowd-pleaser is the “Mediterranean Delight,” topped with kalamata olives, sun-dried tomatoes, feta, and fresh basil.

Bastrop Pizza Co. also offers a full bar and a laid-back yet trendy atmosphere, making it a great spot for date nights or casual hangouts. Their commitment to creativity and quality ingredients keeps locals and visitors coming back for more.

Final Thoughts

No matter your pizza preferences, Bastrop, Texas offers an impressive range of pizzerias that promise delicious pies and memorable dining experiences. From the family-friendly comfort of Paul’s Pizza Parlor to the innovative flavors of Bastrop Pizza Co., these four spots have earned their place as the go-to destinations for pizza lovers in town.

Next time hunger strikes and you’re craving a slice, consider exploring these fantastic Bastrop pizza places. Each offers its own unique take on this beloved dish, ensuring that your pizza cravings are more than satisfied.